Our Institute is best known for its facilitation of archaeological
research by Canadian university-based scholars in Greece. While this is
our primary mission it is not our only one. We are also interested in
the study of Greece and its culture in the broadest sense through the
present using a variety of research methodologies. Related to this goal
is fostering the understanding of the nature and extent of relationships
between Greece and Canada. This fall we will host three lectures that
examine aspects of the recent history of Greece and of Greek immigration
to Canada. Central to each of these historical studies is the use of
archival sources here in Greece, in Canada and elsewhere. You can find
details of our programme (and much more!) on our website: www.cig-icg.gr.
The Canadian documentary film that I promised we would show in the winter is finally available to us this fall. This is “Our Man in Tehran”
which reveals the actual events in 1979 involving the Canadian
ambassador Ken Taylor which were creatively dramatized in the Hollywood
feature film “Argo”. Stay tuned for further announcements with more details!
The Role of Greece in the Origins of the Cold War
To start our program off, on Wednesday evening, October 22nd
at 7:30 PM, James Horncastle, a PhD Candidate at the Stavros Niarchos
Foundation Centre for Hellenic Studies in the Department of History at
Simon Fraser University in British Columbia, will give a lecture. The
title is “Temperature Falling: The Greek Civil War and the Origins of the Cold War”.
Horncastle’s research into the events in Greece in the 1940s has
revealed many facets that are not part of the historical analysis of
this seminal period for the shaping of both contemporary Greece and
international relations. Traditional examinations of the Cold War
usually encompass any political development in the immediate post-Second
World War period until the collapse of the Soviet Union. Nevertheless,
the linkages between the Greek Civil War and the Cold War have often
been obscured, or portrayed in binary terms, which detracts from the
analytical process. Upon critical examination of the available source
material, however, it becomes clear that the Greek Civil War was not
only the first proxy war during the Cold War, but also the arena where
what would become the two opposing blocs defined their own identities.
In so doing, the Greek Civil War helped to shape many of the major
dynamics of what would become the Cold War.
International Meeting on the integrated management of the landscapes of Natura2000 sites
Last Friday and Saturday the Piraeus Bank Group Cultural Foundation
organized a two-day International Meeting in Athens and in Stymphalia
(Peloponnesos) entitled “Cultural Landscapes in Natura2000 Sites: towards a new policy for integrated management of cultural and natural heritage”.
At the request of Gerry Schaus, the President of the Institute’s Board
of Directors, I represented CIG at this impressive event. We were
invited to participate most likely as the Cultural Foundation has its
Museum of the Environment at Stymphalia, overlooking the archaeological site of ancient Stymphalos, which was excavated in the 1990s by a team from the University of British Columbia and Wilfrid Laurier University, and the Cistercian Monastery at Zaraka, investigated by a team from the University of Toronto.
Thirty-eight individuals gave welcoming speeches, chaired sessions
and gave presentations in Athens at the Akropolis Museum and at
Stymphalia at the Museum. They came from Greece, France, Spain, Italy,
Germany, the UK, the Netherlands, and Morocco. The Hellenic Ministries
of the Environment, Energy and Climate Change, of Culture and Sports,
and of Tourism, a number of Greek universities, the European Commission,
European Environmental Agency, Council of Europe, various departments
of UNESCO, UNEP, ICOMOS/IFLA, IFLA Europe, ICCROM, ICOM, AECRC, ICMCL,
WWF-Greece, Europa Nostra, ECOVAST, MEDWET, EBRD, ECSP, the British
Parliament, and the Republic of Cyprus. It is a truly alphabet soup of
acronyms. The Piraeus Bank and its Cultural Foundation (www.piop.gr) were well represented, of course.
The subtitle of the Meeting was in essence the conclusions of the
Meeting in relation to Natura2000 sites. That is that in Europe, at
least, there really is not much difference from natural
landscapes/heritage and cultural landscapes/heritage especially when the
Natura2000 network is taken into consideration. Since this is the case
then there should be a comprehensive management plan for these sites
that integrates these two intertwined landscapes. Such plans should be
sustainable, implementable and enforced while addressing the concerns
and aspirations of all of the stakeholders. A tall order, eh!
There was a steady stream of repetition of the central themes and
concepts (such as mixed landscapes, ecosystems, biodiversity, linkages,
identity, synergies, values, stakeholder engagement, public/private
partnerships, communication, education, and training) as well as
frequent cross-referrals in the presentations. A number clearly had
political agendas behind them. The most notable intervention, both for
the enthusiasm of its delivery and the novelty of its message in this
context, was given by Barry Gardiner, MP from Brent-North in the UK and
the Shadow Minister of the Environment for the opposition Labour Party.
His most important point was that the concept of “Natural Capital” as
an asset was absence from the financial calculations in determining
economic value and importance in the discussion of the environment and
what should be done. He argued that Natural Capital belongs to all
people and that individual interest does not have priority over its uses
or its development. For the environment and the natural landscapes we
are the stewards of the present and the guardians for future
generations. Gardiner was the odd man out in the subtext that Natura2000
sites should be open for a wide variety of development and not allowed
to be “museums”. I believe that the concept of “Natural Capital” can be
matched logically by the concept of “Cultural Capital/Heritage” which is
a non-renewable resource that should belong to everyone and be
protected accordingly for the present and for future generations.
At Stymphalia the theory met practice. The Museum of the Environment
there is most impressive and well worth a visit. The Piraeus Bank is
using the restoration of the wider ecosystem of the reed-clogged Lake
Stymphalos and environs under the title “LIFE Stymphalia Project” as a
model project since 2013 for sustainable integrated management of the
natural and the cultural landscapes. To date, however, the
archaeological heritage of the valley has been mostly absent from these
plans despite the prominence of the ancient city state of Stymphalos’
urban center on the edge of the lake and the Cistercian Monastery
remains nearby. During the attendees’ visit to the acropolis of ancient
Stymphalos to see the present situation in the lake I argued that these
remains should be a core element in their integrated landscapes
management plan. The Institute is willing to assist in adding this
component to the plans with the cooperation of the Ministry of Culture
and Sports.
In retrospect, what stood out most on Saturday were the comments of
the Hellenic Minister of Tourism, Ms. Olga Kefalogianni, on “Cultural
Tourism”. These were made in the context of the integrated management of
the landscape, where a network of regional nodes focused on these
extraordinary (Natura2000 sites) and the ordinary (the remainder of
Greece) landscapes would foster cultural/archaeological tourism,
eco-tourism, gastro-tourism, oino-tourism as well as such activities as
birding, trekking and rock climbing throughout the country. This would
be a multi-faceted network of nodes to encourage visitors to Greece to
venture beyond the few well-known areas of the country. Earlier this
week I happened to see on the internet a brief article reporting a
conference in Athens on the “business of luxury hospitality” in the
Mediterranean. Ms. Kefalogianni gave a keynote speech where she said
that her ministry was preparing to table a “national zoning plan for
tourism” to facilitate the development of high-end resorts featuring
state of the art golf courses and marinas and villas along with the
luxury hotels. As any golfer knows it is very boring to have just one
golf course to play on when you are staying in an area. These proposed
gated complexes for the super wealthy of China, Russia, the Gulf states
and other regions (along with the “celebrities”, of course) would
naturally be in those coastal areas of Greece which have escaped
development so far. It is not clear how the stewardship of these natural
and cultural landscapes and their protection for the future under the
concepts of “Natural Capital” and “Cultural Capital/Heritage” would be
integrated into such large scale interventions in the landscape. Henk
van der Kamp, the President of the European Council of Spatial Planners,
would argue that planning would square this circle.
The meeting was well-organized, there were some stimulating
presentations and the attendees were very well looked after. I met many
individuals working in Greek, European and international organizations
operating on a broader, policy-oriented level relating to the
environment per se than that of most archaeological research endeavors
here. Given this, however, the interest in the cultural landscape and
its formation/transformation over time by many archaeologists working in
Greece is much more relevant to its preservation and appreciation today
than the numerous “conventions”, “protocols”, “directives” and
“treaties” created on a regular basis by technocrats and politicians in
comfortable surroundings in pleasant destinations around the world.
Underneath the hype of the ongoing excavation at Amphipolis and the
growing prospect of early national elections in the wake of the need to
elect early next year a new President of the Hellenic Republic, there
are many things happening that have and will affect the future of
archaeology in Greece as well as the country’s cultural landscapes and
heritage.
Cordially,
David Rupp
Director